Former abuser who suspended boys from roof rafters tries to obtain legal parenthood of surrogate child

A 76-year-old American man previously convicted of abusing multiple children paid a surrogate mother to give birth to a baby boy whom he intended to raise alone, according to court documents obtained by The Federalist.

Sanford S Kaplan, a former geologist from Colorado, entered into a surrogacy agreement with a woman in Texas in February 2025, reportedly paying approximately $50,000 (£38,000) for her to carry a child conceived using his sperm and a donor egg.

Under the agreement, Kaplan would receive immediate and sole custody of the baby following his birth. Court documents indicate that Kaplan was able to select the child’s sex and chose a boy.

However, Kaplan had previously been convicted of abusing boys aged between 10 and 15 while working as a youth football coach in Nebraska.

Between the 1990s and 2009, Kaplan subjected children to disturbing abuse, including blindfolding, restraining, and suspending them from rafters in his garage.

In 2009, he pleaded no contest to seven counts of child abuse and one count of false imprisonment. He received a 24-year prison sentence but was released after serving approximately seven years.

Despite this history, Kaplan’s surrogacy arrangement was approved by a Texas court in August 2025, after a requirement for a home study assessing the child’s prospective living conditions was waived.

The arrangement subsequently unravelled when hospital staff raised concerns shortly before the baby’s birth in November 2025.

The Texas Department of Family and Protective Services intervened, preventing Kaplan from taking custody.

According to an affidavit presented to the court, Kaplan acknowledged additional victims beyond those identified in his original prosecution, estimating that he had abused between 17 and 18 children.

The surrogate mother, identified only as SM, reportedly told investigators that Kaplan had concealed his criminal history from her.

His own lawyer subsequently withdrew from the case, alleging that Kaplan had misrepresented his convictions to both legal representatives and the court.

In August 2026, a Travis County jury terminated Kaplan’s parental rights, determining that his previous conduct endangered the child.

The baby remains in foster care under the supervision of child protection authorities and reportedly has documented medical needs.

Kaplan filed an appeal in October and continues to contest the decision.

The case highlights a worrying loophole in commercial surrogacy arrangement that apply in the US and Britain. Unlike in cases of adoption there are often fewer or no welfare checks for commissioning parents, allowing designer babies to go to unsafe homes.

The child, created by Kaplan to be intentionally motherless, will now be raised without both his biological parents.

SPUC’s Communications Manager Peter Kearney has commented on the case saying, “We see yet another horrific surrogacy story where the most dangerous people in society are renting out the wombs of women to bring new victims into their homes. Whether it be the lack of checks, the dangers of intentional single parenthood, or the eugenic selection of children, the growth of commercial surrogacy across the globe leaves children with their safety compromised. We at SPUC are pleased to see a growing move to ban surrogacy and hope to see its success in Britain, the US, and throughout the world.”



@spucprolife
Please enter your email if you would like to stay in touch with us and receive our latest news directly in your inbox.