News from the scientific world has once again unsettled those who value the sanctity of human life. The Telegraph recently reported that researchers claim to have created what they called “motherless babies” in the laboratory. The method involved taking skin cells and reprogramming them into eggs, replacing the woman’s DNA with genetic material from another man. A dazzling breakthrough for some, but it raises profound questions about how we view human identity, unborn life, and the role of mothers in bringing children into the world.
For centuries, women have borne the irreplaceable role of bearing and nurturing life. Yet here we see the return of a troubling trend in fertility technology, where women risk being shunned, sidelined, or reduced to genetic bystanders. Hijacking an egg cell by replacing the woman’s contribution with another man’s DNA treats mothers as dispensable. Far from liberating women, such advances risk erasing their unique vocation in family life and childbearing.
The scientific claims also cast light on how far researchers are prepared to go in manipulating life for the sake of novelty. Creating children in a laboratory is not progress if it forgets that children are not products. They are persons with dignity, rights, and inherent worth. The notion that a child could be designed without a mother cuts against the natural order of family and the complementarity of the sexes. It reflects a vision of science untethered from moral responsibility.
The Telegraph’s report made clear that this is still at an experimental stage, but the ethical problems are already plain. Whenever scientists cross the threshold from research to the creation of embryonic human beings, the question of respect for life arises. These embryos are not abstractions or “test material”. They are nascent human lives, each carrying the full genetic code of a new person, however tiny and fragile.
The Telegraph’s own social media coverage revealed that nine embryos were grown to a stage considered viable for IVF implantation. They were then, in the words of the report, “destroyed in accordance with ethical guidelines”. SPUC sees through such sanitised language. It is not ethical to deliberately end the lives of viable 14-day-old babies.
What really happened is that living human beings were created and then mercilessly killed in a lab to satisfy scientific vanity.
If you’re reading this and haven’t yet donated to SPUC, please consider helping now. Thank You!
