Image – Shutterstock: Joseph Sohm
A man convicted of attempting to assassinate US President Donald Trump has asked to serve his sentence in a state where assisted suicide is permitted, prompting fresh debate about the practice and its implications for vulnerable people.
Ryan Routh, found guilty last month of plotting to kill Mr Trump while he played golf in Florida, made the request in a letter to US District Judge Aileen Cannon. In the letter, Routh described himself as a “constant failure” and expressed a wish to be placed in a prison that allows what he called “medical aid in dying”.
Routh, who represented himself after dismissing his public defenders, has also suggested that his life could be exchanged for that of an international prisoner, claiming to have contacted “countless” foreign ministries with such offers. “Trade me for a Palestinian prisoner in Israel, or a prisoner of war in Russia,” he wrote, adding, “Do not let me take my own life and it have zero benefit for humanity.”
His comments follow a dramatic moment in court last month when, after hearing the guilty verdict, he attempted to stab himself in the neck with a pen before being restrained by US marshals. He was later returned to the courtroom in shackles.
Although judges in the United States can recommend where a defendant serves their sentence, the Federal Bureau of Prisons ultimately decides the placement. Eleven US states, along with Washington, D.C., currently permit assisted suicide for terminally ill adults. Critics have warned that such laws can blur moral boundaries and risk influencing those who are mentally unwell or socially isolated.
Routh’s case, a display of severe psychological distress, has reignited questions about the intersection of choice and capacity in the assisted suicide debate. Like with the case of Australian paedophile, Daniel Hume, who was allowed assisted suicide next to a photo of his victims, SPUC warns that allowing assisted suicide in the UK could upend the justice system. Guilty people should not be allowed such an easy escape from the consequences of their crimes.
If you’re reading this and haven’t yet donated to SPUC, please consider helping now. Thank You!
